Understanding Build-Time vs. Runtime Environment Variables in JavaScript: Key Differences and Best Practices

In JavaScript development, especially with frameworks like Node.js and Next.js, understanding how environment variables work is essential for configuring applications effectively. Environment variables provide a way to pass dynamic configuration into your code without hardcoding values. But did you know there's a significant difference between build-time and runtime environment variables? In this article, we'll dive into these distinctions, highlight best practices, and consider some factors you may not have thought about before.

What Are Environment Variables?

Environment variables are a set of key-value pairs that define settings or configuration values for applications. These values can include API keys, database URLs, public API endpoints, or any other configuration that may differ depending on the environment (development, testing, production).

Build-Time Environment Variables

Build-time environment variables are variables that get captured and embedded into the application during the build process. Once the application is built (or compiled), these values are effectively “baked in” and can’t be changed without rebuilding the application.

Key Characteristics:

• Static values: Build-time variables remain constant and do not change after the build. If you need a new value, you must rebuild the application.
• Ideal for public configurations: Build-time variables are commonly used for public-facing configurations that won’t change, such as a public API endpoint that the client-side JavaScript will access.
• Optimization benefits: Some frameworks, like Next.js, use these variables to optimize code during the build, potentially eliminating unused code paths or configurations.

Example:

Suppose you're building a weather application in Next.js and need to specify the URL of a public weather API endpoint. You might use a build-time variable like this:

console.log(process.env.NEXT_PUBLIC_WEATHER_API_URL);

Here, NEXT_PUBLIC_WEATHER_API_URL will stay the same in production until you rebuild the app with a new value in your .env file.

Pros and Cons of Build-Time Variables:

• Pros: Consistent, predictable values, useful for static configurations, potential for performance optimization.
• Cons: Requires rebuild to update, less flexibility for changes once deployed.

Runtime Environment Variables

In contrast, runtime environment variables are defined when the application starts and can vary each time the application is run. These variables are set by the server, container, or platform (e.g., Docker, Kubernetes, CI/CD environments) and allow for much greater flexibility.

Key Characteristics:

• Dynamic values: Runtime variables can differ between application restarts, allowing for flexible, environment-specific configurations.
• Perfect for sensitive data: Runtime variables are ideal for handling sensitive information like API keys, database URLs, or tokens since they’re injected at runtime, not hardcoded.
• Compatibility with various environments: Different configurations can be applied across development, testing, and production environments without needing to rebuild.

Example:

In a Node.js application, you might set a runtime variable for connecting to a database:

console.log(process.env.DATABASE_URL);

You can specify this value right before running the application:

DATABASE_URL="postgres://user:password@localhost:5432/mydb" node app.js

This allows you to modify DATABASE_URL for testing or production without modifying or rebuilding your code.

Pros and Cons of Runtime Variables:

• Pros: Flexibility, ideal for sensitive data, no need to rebuild to change.
• Cons: Values may differ across environments, making debugging harder in certain cases.

Best Practices and Considerations

Here are some additional points to keep in mind when using environment variables:

1. Naming Conventions Matter

Using clear and consistent naming conventions for environment variables is critical. For instance, prefixing build-time variables with something like NEXT_PUBLIC_ can indicate they are intended for client-side use. This also helps avoid potential conflicts.

2. Security Risks of Client-Side Environment Variables

Be aware that client-side environment variables (public variables) embedded at build time are exposed to anyone who can access your application. Avoid putting any sensitive information in these variables; they’re visible in the browser’s dev tools. Instead, keep sensitive data on the server side and pass it to the client only when absolutely necessary.

3. Use a .env File and Keep It Secure

A .env file is often used to store environment variables in a local development environment. However, it should never be committed to version control since it may contain sensitive information. Use .gitignore to prevent it from being included in your repository.

4. Leverage Environment Variable Management Tools

For larger applications, consider using environment variable management tools like dotenv, Vault, or AWS Secrets Manager. These tools help you securely store and manage environment variables across different environments, especially for runtime configurations.

5. Version-Controlled Configuration Files for Build Variables

If your build-time environment variables are part of a .env file, consider creating a version-controlled example file (.env.example) that includes placeholders. This helps other developers understand required configurations without exposing sensitive information.

6. Consider Containerization for Complex Environments

If your application requires multiple configurations across environments, containerization with tools like Docker can make it easier to manage runtime variables. Docker allows you to pass environment variables when launching containers, ensuring you have a consistent, repeatable setup.

7. Understand the Framework’s Support for Environment Variables

Each framework has different ways to handle environment variables. For example:

• Next.js only allows environment variables prefixed with NEXT_PUBLIC_ to be accessed on the client side.
• Node.js applications can access all environment variables server-side without restriction.

When to Use Build-Time vs. Runtime Variables

Here are some general rules of thumb:

• Use build-time variables for:
  • Public-facing configuration values that won’t change often.
  • Values that need to be optimized into the build for performance, such as API URLs for static content.
• Use runtime variables for:
  • Sensitive information, like API tokens, that should not be exposed in the client.
  • Configurations that need to change across different environments, such as staging or production, without rebuilding.

Finally

Managing environment variables effectively is crucial for both security and maintainability in any JavaScript project. While build-time variables offer a stable, optimized configuration, runtime variables provide flexibility and security, especially for sensitive data. By understanding these differences and following best practices, you’ll be well-equipped to handle environment configurations in your applications safely and effectively.

Support Us