Understanding FIND_IN_SET in MySQL: The Key to Searching Comma-Separated Values

When working with relational databases, data normalization is often recommended. However, there are scenarios where a single column may hold comma-separated values (CSV), typically for legacy systems or specific use cases. MySQL's FIND_IN_SET function is a lifesaver for handling such data. This article explores the usage, examples, and considerations for FIND_IN_SET, ensuring you can use it effectively.

What Is FIND_IN_SET?

FIND_IN_SET is a built-in MySQL function that searches for a specific string within a comma-separated list of strings. If the string is found, it returns its 1-based position in the list. If not found, it returns 0.

This function is particularly useful when filtering or sorting data stored in comma-separated fields, such as tags, categories, or options.

Syntax

FIND_IN_SET(string_to_find, string_list)

Parameters:

• string_to_find: The value you are searching for.
• string_list: The comma-separated list to search within.

Examples

1. Basic Usage

The simplest use case of FIND_IN_SET is finding the position of a value in a string list.

SELECT FIND_IN_SET('apple', 'banana,apple,orange') AS position;

Result:

Here, 'apple' is the second item in the list, so the result is 2.

2. Using FIND_IN_SET in a WHERE Clause

Suppose you have a fruits table:

To find all rows containing 'apple':

SELECT *
FROM fruits
WHERE FIND_IN_SET('apple', fruit_list) > 0;

Result:

3. Using FIND_IN_SET for Sorting

You can leverage FIND_IN_SET to order results based on the position of a value in a list:

SELECT id, fruit_list, FIND_IN_SET('banana', fruit_list) AS position
FROM fruits
ORDER BY position;

Result:

Rows where 'banana' is not found will have a position of 0 and appear first.

4. Performance Considerations

While FIND_IN_SET is handy, it comes with caveats:

1. Inefficient on Large Datasets: Since FIND_IN_SET performs a string search, it doesn't utilize indexes. This can lead to performance issues on large datasets. Use it sparingly or as a temporary solution.
2. Not for Normalized Data: It works only with comma-separated values, which often indicate a lack of normalization. Where possible, consider normalizing your data by splitting the CSV into related tables.
3. Case-Sensitivity: The function is case-sensitive, meaning 'Apple' and 'apple' are treated as different values. If case-insensitivity is required, consider using LOWER() or UPPER():

SELECT FIND_IN_SET(LOWER('Apple'), LOWER(fruit_list)) AS position;

4. Limited to Commas: FIND_IN_SET does not support other delimiters like semicolons or pipes. If your data uses a different delimiter, you'll need to replace it with commas before using FIND_IN_SET.

Best Practices and Alternatives

Normalize Your Data

Instead of relying on FIND_IN_SET, consider designing your schema to avoid storing comma-separated values. For instance:

Instead of:

Create two tables:

articles Table:

article_tags Table:

Now you can perform searches with standard SQL joins, which are indexed and faster.

Use JSON Columns (if applicable)

For modern MySQL versions, JSON columns are a powerful alternative. They offer better flexibility and indexing than CSV fields.

Example:

CREATE TABLE articles (
    id INT AUTO_INCREMENT PRIMARY KEY,
    tags JSON
);

INSERT INTO articles (tags) VALUES ('["mysql", "sql", "php"]');

To find rows containing a specific tag:

SELECT *
FROM articles
WHERE JSON_CONTAINS(tags, '"mysql"');

Use LIKE for Basic Searches

If performance isn't a concern, and you want to find rows containing a specific value, you can use LIKE:

SELECT *
FROM fruits
WHERE fruit_list LIKE '%apple%';

However, this method may yield false positives (e.g., 'pineapple' will match 'apple').

Finally

• FIND_IN_SET is powerful for working with comma-separated fields but should be used judiciously.
• It works best for small datasets or legacy systems where normalization isn't feasible.
• Consider normalizing your data or using JSON columns for scalable solutions.
• Always weigh performance trade-offs when working with functions like FIND_IN_SET.

By understanding the strengths and limitations of FIND_IN_SET, you can make informed decisions when dealing with comma-separated values in MySQL. While it’s a convenient tool, remember that the best solution often lies in designing your database for scalability and efficiency.

Support Us