Why Base64 May Not Be the Best Solution for Binary Data Transmission and How Multipart HTTP Requests Can Help

In the world of web development and APIs, sending binary data efficiently is a challenge many face. One common approach is using Base64 encoding, but while it may seem like a straightforward solution, it introduces several issues that can degrade your system's performance. If you’re wondering whether there’s a better way to handle binary data in web applications, the answer lies in multipart HTTP requests. This article will explore the limitations of Base64 encoding, how multipart requests can help, and why you should consider treating binary data differently in your applications.

The Problem with Base64 Encoding for Binary Data

When we talk about Base64 encoding, we are referring to the process of converting binary data (such as images or videos) into a string of ASCII characters. The reasoning behind this is that many systems, especially web protocols like HTTP, are optimized for text-based communication. Binary data, on the other hand, can sometimes cause problems in these text-oriented systems. Base64 seems like a quick fix because it converts binary into a textual format that is easier to handle.

However, Base64 encoding comes with a price. Here are the key downsides you need to be aware of:

1. Data Size Increase
   Base64 encoding increases the size of the original data by approximately 33%. For example, if you have a 1 MB image, after encoding it into Base64, it will become around 1.33 MB. This means you’re sending more data than necessary, which can lead to slower transfers, higher bandwidth usage, and potentially increased latency.
2. Increased CPU and Memory Usage
   Base64 encoding and decoding require extra processing power. The process of converting binary data to Base64 on the sender’s side and decoding it back on the receiver’s side can significantly increase CPU usage. If you're working with large files or many simultaneous requests, this added burden on your server can negatively affect performance, especially in resource-constrained environments. Additionally, Base64 data consumes more memory since the data is stored as a string instead of its more compact binary format.
3. Network Overhead
   Sending larger data over the network not only consumes more bandwidth but also increases the likelihood of packet fragmentation. This can lead to additional latency in the network and impact the overall speed of data transfer. Especially when dealing with large files, the inefficiencies of Base64 become apparent.

Multipart HTTP Requests: The Better Alternative

Now, let’s consider a more efficient way to transmit binary data: multipart HTTP requests. These requests allow you to send files as they are, without converting them into Base64. Multipart requests break the data into multiple parts, each with its own content type, making them an ideal choice for file uploads and data transmission.

Here’s how multipart HTTP requests work and why they are more efficient than Base64:

1. Multipart Requests Structure
   A multipart HTTP request is a special type of HTTP request that allows you to send multiple pieces of data in one request. The data is divided into parts, where each part can contain its own content type, header, and data. Each part of the request is separated by a boundary marker, defined in the Content-Type header of the request.For example, when a user uploads a file through a web form, the data is split into several parts:The parts are separated by a boundary string that the server and client can easily parse. Here’s an example of how the headers and data for a multipart request might look:

• Textual data (such as form fields like names, emails, etc.) will be sent in one part.
• Binary data (like images, PDFs, or videos) will be sent in another part.

POST /upload HTTP/1.1
Content-Type: multipart/form-data; boundary=----WebKitFormBoundary7MA4YWxkTrZu0gW

------WebKitFormBoundary7MA4YWxkTrZu0gW
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="user"; filename="profile.png"
Content-Type: image/png

[binary data of the image]

------WebKitFormBoundary7MA4YWxkTrZu0gW
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="username"

johndoe
------WebKitFormBoundary7MA4YWxkTrZu0gW--

In this example:

• The Content-Type header specifies that the request is multipart/form-data and defines the boundary string.
• The binary image data (profile.png) is sent in one part, while the text (username=johndoe) is sent in another.
• Each part is separated by the boundary string (----WebKitFormBoundary7MA4YWxkTrZu0gW), which helps the server identify where one part ends and another begins.

2. No Data Bloat
   One of the biggest advantages of multipart requests is that files are sent in their original binary form. This means that the file size does not increase, and you’re transmitting the data exactly as it is. No encoding, no extra overhead. This makes multipart requests much more efficient in terms of data size.
3. Flexible and Structured
   Multipart requests support multiple parts in one HTTP request, which means you can send both binary data (such as images or documents) and text data (like form fields) in a single request. This is especially useful in forms where you might need to upload an image along with user details. The structure of multipart requests is very flexible and can handle various data types in the same request.
4. Better Support for File Uploads
   Multipart is the standard for file uploads over HTTP. Popular frameworks and libraries like HTML forms and API clients (e.g., Postman) use multipart to handle file uploads seamlessly. For example, HTML forms with the enctype="multipart/form-data" attribute allow users to upload files directly from the browser without needing to convert them to Base64.
5. Efficient Network and CPU Usage
   By sending data in its raw form, multipart requests help reduce network overhead and avoid unnecessary CPU-intensive encoding and decoding steps. This translates to faster uploads and downloads with less resource consumption on both the client and server.

What About Non-Textual Data?

It’s important to note that not everything on the web is text. Many people assume that all HTTP requests are text-based, but in reality, HTTP can handle a wide variety of content types. These include everything from binary files (e.g., images, videos, audio) to JSON, XML, and more.

Using multipart requests for binary data allows us to send different types of content in their native formats without unnecessary transformations. Here are some common Content-Type headers for various types of data:

• application/json for JSON data
• application/xml for XML data
• image/png, image/jpeg, audio/mpeg, etc., for binary file formats

This allows you to avoid the pitfalls of Base64 and handle binary and non-binary data efficiently.

Other Considerations

1. Error Handling
   Multipart requests often come with built-in mechanisms for handling errors. If a part of the multipart request fails (for example, a file exceeds the server’s size limit), it’s easier to identify and address the issue without disrupting the entire request. This flexibility can make error handling more robust compared to Base64-encoded data, where issues like corruption can be harder to debug.
2. Security and Integrity
   Since Base64 encoding doesn’t offer any encryption or hashing, it doesn’t add any security to the data. Multipart requests, on the other hand, allow for more secure transmission of data when combined with HTTPS. Additionally, you can use hashing techniques to ensure data integrity during the transfer process.
3. Compatibility with HTTP/2 and HTTP/3
   Multipart requests are fully compatible with modern versions of HTTP, such as HTTP/2 and HTTP/3, which offer performance improvements like multiplexing and header compression. This makes multipart requests even more attractive as they can leverage these newer protocols for better overall performance.

Finally: Choose the Right Tool for the Job

While Base64 encoding might seem like an easy way to send binary data through text-based systems, it’s often not the best option in terms of performance. The size increase, CPU load, and network inefficiencies it introduces can significantly affect your application’s responsiveness and scalability.

Instead, consider using multipart HTTP requests, which allow you to send binary data in its original format, minimizing overhead and maximizing efficiency. With better performance, flexibility, and resource management, multipart requests are a far more suitable option for modern web applications.

Remember: not everything on the internet needs to be converted into text, and by using the right tools for the job, you can make your application faster, more efficient, and more scalable.

Support Us