Why Redux Feels “Unpredictable” Without DevTools — Even Though It’s Not

Redux is known for its predictability. That’s literally what it promises: given a state and an action, you always get the same next state. But let’s be honest — when you’re working on a real app, especially a large one, it doesn’t always feel that way.

In fact, many developers feel like Redux is unmanageable or confusing unless Redux DevTools is open and logging everything. So why is that? Why does something designed to be predictable feel the opposite?

Let’s dig in.

🔄 Redux Is Predictable... Just Not Always Visibly

At its core, Redux is governed by three principles:

1. Single source of truth – All your app state lives in one tree.
2. State is read-only – You can’t mutate state directly.
3. Changes happen through pure functions – Reducers must be pure and predictable.

So far, so good. That sounds solid, and it is.

But the issue isn’t with Redux’s logic — it’s with how we work with Redux in complex environments.

💣 What Makes Redux Feel Unpredictable

1. The Mental Overhead Is Real

Even if each reducer is pure, your brain still has to:

• Keep track of which component dispatched which action
• Know what middleware did in between (like redux-thunk, redux-saga, etc.)
• Understand how state from one slice affects another

When your app grows, your mental map of state transitions breaks down.

So while Redux is still doing the right thing, you no longer feel in control of how state changes over time.

2. You Lose the Cause-and-Effect Chain

React updates the UI reactively — you see a change, but you don’t always know:

• Why it changed
• What caused the dispatch
• Which part of the state changed

Without logs or tooling, it’s hard to trace the chain:

User clicked → Action dispatched → Middleware ran → Reducer updated state → Component re-rendered

That’s a lot of invisible steps without DevTools.

3. Middleware Adds a Black Box Effect

When you use redux-thunk or redux-saga, you’re handling:

• Async flows
• Conditional dispatching
• Chained or delayed effects

These are powerful, but they also hide logic away from reducers and scatter it across thunks or sagas.

So again, Redux is working as intended — but you have no timeline of events unless you log everything manually or use DevTools.

🛠️ Why DevTools Are a Lifeline

Redux DevTools doesn’t just make debugging easier — it makes Redux usable at scale.

With it, you can:

• Track every dispatched action
• View state diffs before and after
• Time travel to earlier states
• Replay bugs by exporting logs

That’s not just “nice to have.” In real-world apps, DevTools are the difference between chaos and control.

⚖️ Why Other State Tools Feel More Predictable Without Tooling

Libraries like Zustand, Jotai, or even Svelte store feel more “natural” because:

• State is often co-located with the component
• You can directly inspect the store in simple console logs
• Logic is easier to follow because it’s less abstracted

That’s why Redux can sometimes feel “bloated” — not because it’s wrong, but because it demands tooling to be developer-friendly.

✅ Tips to Make Redux Feel Predictable (Without DevTools)

If you want to tame Redux even without fancy tooling, consider:

• Creating custom logging middleware to track actions/state
• Keeping reducers small and focused
• Naming your actions clearly (avoid vague names like UPDATE_STATE)
• Avoiding over-centralization — not all state needs to live in Redux
• Grouping logic per domain (features/user, features/cart, etc.)

You can also write unit tests for reducers — they are pure, so they’re easy to test and reason about.

🧭 Finally

Redux is technically predictable, but that predictability is only useful if you can see and trace it. Without visibility, Redux can feel like a maze, even if it’s doing the right thing behind the scenes.

So if you’re using Redux:

• Embrace DevTools — they exist because Redux is powerful and abstract.
• Don’t feel bad if Redux seems complex — it is, and that’s okay.
• And if it ever feels too heavy, maybe your app doesn’t need it anymore. There are plenty of simpler, scoped alternatives today.

In the end, predictability means nothing if you can’t observe it — and that’s why Redux DevTools makes all the difference.

Support Us